Thursday, January 19, 2006
THE SECOND LIFE OF LAWRENCE LESSIG, PART I
Hamlet Linden: About three years ago, Stanford legal scholar Lawrence Lessig stood before the nine Justices of the United States Supreme Court. From one perspective, he was arguing over the interpretation of a single sentence in the US Constitution.
From another angle, he was fighting for the very future of ideas and art-- in America, and by extension, the world.
His most recent book, Free Culture, is a story of that ongoing battle-- what led up to it, how he fought it, and where we can go in the aftermath of the Court's decision. And though it may seem strange, it's actually quite appropriate that he takes his case here (so to speak), in avatar form. As we'll soon find out.
So ladies and gentlemen, from the office of Linden Lab in San Francisco and this hilltop auditorium of Pooley, please join me in welcoming Professor Lawrence Lessig.
Before I turn you over to Philip Linden, I wanted to start off with a few questions on Free Culture to set the context. Let's say you get in the elevator with Senator Orrin Hatch and Daniel Robert Glickman, the new head of the MPAA-- what point from Free Culture would you convey to them, in the short time you have?
Philip Linden [grinning]: We all do that at least once.
Lawrence Lessig: So the thing Orrin should be asked is this: how come the government is spending so much energy regulating creativity? Where's the Republican in that? And second, how come spending so much time protecting this powerful industry against competition, rather than embracing competition as the way we find a new world. Two quick questions before floor three.
HL: Now let's say Senator Hatch and Glickman get out, and in comes a kid who likes to download lots of music and movies via peer to peer-- what point from Free Culture would you convey to him?
LL: I don't have anything to tell the kid. The kid is teaching us something. If you look at the creativity kids have demonstrated using digital technology, that's enough to say that we, professors, lawyers, congressmen, should listen, not lecture.
HL: But what do you tell him [if] he wants to get involved with teaching us more?
LL: Well, he should want to teach us more, because we or the government are quite good at destroying. And the one thing they seem most keen to do is to use the law to protect dying industries, and in that way destroy new worlds. So to speak.
PL: Potentially literally!
HL: It's been nearly two years since Free Culture was published. What significant changes in the world of media and the entertainment industry have you seen since then, and how have they enhanced or modified the arguments you were making in the book?
LL: The explosion of what I call (but would love a better word for) the "read write Internet". The key thing we're seeing now is the Internet used to create and remix culture. The focus two years ago was peer to peer filesharing. But the focus today is the stuff that happens here [in Second Life]. Or in mashups. Or with remixed music. Or anime music videos. This capacity and this creativity is extraordinary. And yet the "war" that that the copyright industry is waging against "piracy" will kill it. At least as a legitimate part of culture.
HL: Tell me a little bit about pleading the Eldred case before the Supreme Court in 2002, and how difficult it was to write about the experience so self-critically.
LL: So Eldred began in 1998. I was a new professor at Harvard. I was a believer in what the law could do. I saw this law -- the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act. An act that extended the term of copyright for EXISTING works by 20 years. [Eric Eldred wanted to continue uploading works of literature online, as they entered the public domain, and sued for the right to continue doing so against the Bono Act. - HL] The 11th extension of existing copyright terms in 40 years. And I compared it to the Constitution, which says that Congress has the power to PROMOTE THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE by securing FOR LIMITED TIMES exclusive rights to authors for their writings. And it was clear to me that current practice was inconsistent with the framers’ intent.
Now I had clerked for Justice Scalia. An originalist. A conservative. And so I knew quite well the philosophy of the conservatives. And they believe that you interpret and apply the Constitution as it was originally intended. So I thought: great, we go to the Supreme Court, we show them this law and the original Constitution, and the conservatives will agree with us because of originalism and the liberals will agree with us because of the burden on free speech, and we'll get nine (actually eight -- there's one really pro-copyright person on the Court) on our side.
It was insanely naive.
When we got close to the argument at the Supreme Court, a friend, a law professor, said to me: so I'm convinced you're right on the law. But tell me the last time the Supreme Court voted against all the money in the world.
I told him he was being really boring. That's not how the Court thinks.
He understood something more than I.
HL: In your argument before the Supreme Court, Justice Kennedy asks you for empirical evidence that extending copyright has impeded cultural progress. You keep the focus on a point of Constitutional law, though you now regret not citing such evidence. If you could do it over again, what empirical evidence would you give Justice Kennedy and the Court?
LL: Yeah. It was a good question. The problem is it's hard to point to evidence as in stuff people have counted. But things since then have made the issue clearer. Think for example about the Google book search project. Google wants to index 18,000,000 books and make them searchable. If the book is in copyright, you'll get a "snippet" around the search. If it is not in copyright, then you can see the full book. Of the 18 million books, 16% are out of copyright. 9% are in copyright and in print.
That means 75% are in copyright, but out of print.
Now the publishers say you need to ask permission before you index these books. But how do you ask the 75% of 18 million authors when we have no list of copyright owners, no record of who owns the rights, no way to track down current claimants at all. Yet it stands in the way-- and now threatens Google with a huge law suit-- because the term gets extended and extended. The term for the framers was 14 years, renewable once. It is now life of the author plus 70 years-- which for someone creating in the way Irving Berlin did, would be 140 years.
So, Justice Kennedy, does blocking access to 50-75% of the books in our tradition constitute a burden on our culture?
HL: If you said all that, do you think the case could have turned your way?
LL: People who know stuff say there was no way to win. I still think that two things could have changed their view.
First, I should have been meaner to the conservatives. I should have held their feet to the fire of their own principles-- directly telling them that they couldn't consistently decide that Congress was free to make up whatever term they wanted and that it was limited in all the ways the conservatives have limited Congress. It should have been framed as a-- you choose-- principled or political, question.
The second thing would have been to make the case less about Mickey Mouse, and more about the rest of culture that gets locked up just so we can protect Mickey. Probably 90% of the creativity that had its copyright extended is not commercially available at all. For creativity like films, that means that that works is totally inaccessible.
And when the copyrights for those films expire, the works themselves will literally have expired-- film decays; it will be dust before the copyright ends.
The point is they should recognize that they're choosing-- either help Mickey, or help preserve and make accessible our culture-- at least on terms different from the terms that Hollywood offers.
HL: OK, I think that sets the framework for the book-- I want to turn over the floor to Philip to let him discuss your relation to Second Life and other themes of these ideas impacting with virtual worlds.
Posted at 01:13 AM | Permalink
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference THE SECOND LIFE OF LAWRENCE LESSIG, PART I:
» Transcript of Lessig's in-game interview from Boing Boing
Lawrence Lessig conducted an in-game interview in Second Life, a virtual world that allows players to assign Creative Commons licenses to their in-game works. The lightly edited transcript is online and as always, it's fascinating reading: HL: In your ... [Read More]
Tracked on Jan 24, 2006 7:01:05 AM
Tracked on Jan 24, 2006 11:02:30 AM
Tracked on Jun 2, 2006 7:31:28 PM
Tracked on Jun 10, 2006 2:26:38 PM
» States and Capitals from All USA States
State information resource links to state homepage, symbols, flags, maps, constitutions, ... All Rights Reserved. Press Ctrl - D to bookmark this page. ... [Read More]
Tracked on Jul 17, 2006 7:56:44 AM
Tracked on Jul 27, 2006 7:55:21 AM
Tracked on Aug 4, 2006 7:44:50 AM
» burberry from Burberry Perfume
Buy Burberry perfumes and aftershaves from the best UK shops online. Click on one of the products listed below to compare prices to find the best price to ... [Read More]
Tracked on Aug 4, 2006 8:16:30 AM
» It?s Raining Unlimited Cash at Wealth Madness Live ? Wealth-Building Seminar to Create Cash-Generation Storm of the Century from seminar will
lucrative trade. (PRWEB Aug 1, 2006) Trackback URL: [Read More]
Tracked on Aug 7, 2006 8:28:15 PM
Tracked on Aug 8, 2006 9:03:19 PM
Tracked on Aug 9, 2006 7:50:38 AM
Tracked on Aug 14, 2006 11:09:55 AM
» Physicians Wanted for Free Listing; New Web Site Offers Mesothelioma or Asbestos Related Cancer Victims/Potential Victims Assistance, Information from advocacy group
a web site dedicated to public information and physician contacts related to Mesothelioma and or other asbestos related diseases. The site is [Read More]
Tracked on Aug 14, 2006 12:45:52 PM
Tracked on Aug 16, 2006 2:42:37 PM
Tracked on Sep 1, 2009 5:04:03 PM
Tracked on Sep 2, 2009 9:12:55 PM
Tracked on Sep 3, 2009 7:18:12 PM
Tracked on Sep 17, 2009 1:25:50 AM
Hamlet, I thought it was going to be full ... so how comes in the screenshots there are so many empty seats?
Posted by: Mike at Jan 19, 2006 2:20:58 PM
Partly because people are spread out all around the auditorium, and SL doesn't always display all avatars in crowded adjoining sims (you'd have to ask a technical Linden why). All I can say the audience was 100+ throughout.
Posted by: Hamlet Linden at Jan 19, 2006 3:07:36 PM
Posted by: tommy at May 31, 2007 3:12:41 AM
Honesty, integrity and a persuasive mentality are the most important qualities of an elected official
Posted by: ayurslim at Jul 14, 2007 7:55:18 PM
I've basically been doing nothing to speak of. Pretty much nothing exciting happening. I haven't been up to anything lately. My life's been really bland these days, but it's not important. Not much on my mind today.
Posted by: beer supply wine at Aug 11, 2007 10:46:54 AM
Thank's for the very informative site, these sites are some I would recommend.
the number one website for online craps. Hope you enjoy them.
Posted by: bingo at Aug 29, 2007 5:04:30 AM
casino informasjon for Norske spillere vedrørende mahjong, spilleautomater på nett og generell online casino informasjon finner du på http://www.nettcasino.com. Dette er en side som vil gi deg de beste stedene for online bingo og casino poker på nett.
Posted by: Casino at Sep 6, 2007 7:04:56 AM
College education is a basic need today
Posted by: fetishpass at Sep 21, 2007 9:31:51 PM
arranged marriages should be, should not be outlawed
Posted by: album at Sep 29, 2007 6:14:27 PM
I grandi vecchi delle dittature mondiali si spengono. Fidel è grave e ieri è morto Pinochet, ironia della sorte nella
Posted by: bab at Oct 4, 2007 4:22:20 PM
Prisons treat, don't treat prisoners too well
Posted by: sam at Oct 8, 2007 5:15:33 PM
Fast food causes obesity
Posted by: rear at Oct 16, 2007 8:37:11 AM
I came to the conclusion that I thought it was extremely difficult for forex broker’s to manipulate price as there were just too many variables that worked against the forex broker. Some of these being the fact that the manipulating forex broker would need to assume that you keep your stop order(s) at the price you’ve set, and that there are likely to be no other forex traders taking advantage on the manipulated price.
Posted by: online trading software at Apr 2, 2009 6:29:09 AM
The best time to learn is before you're in the thick of things. Wise readers will keep reading to earn some valuable experience while it's still free. - William B. Doyle, http://www.wbdoyle.com/blog/
Posted by: gbp exchange rates at Jun 22, 2009 5:40:38 AM
Thanks to the author for a good story. My opinion differs from yours, but I am willing to reconsider their views.
Posted by: Paydaymister at Dec 2, 2009 1:21:57 PM
Thanks to your article I really liked. Be sure to add your blog to their favorites
Posted by: Antiagingmen at Dec 3, 2009 12:57:13 AM
Thank you for a good story, I really enjoyed your blog. Be sure to give a link to your friends!
Posted by: Paydaymen at Dec 27, 2009 10:08:17 AM
Hello, I want to congratulate your site with 2010. I am sure that, in this new year, your article will please his readers.
Posted by: Dublemen at Jan 9, 2010 11:57:15 PM
President Obama promised $100 million and the full resources of the U.S. government for what he said would be one of the largest relief efforts in recent history. U.S. officials said 30 countries had either sent aid or promised to do so. Rescue teams from eight countries were on the ground.
Posted by: Graypayday at Jan 15, 2010 1:48:06 AM
hello buddy I want to read THE SECOND LIFE OF LAWRENCE LESSIG, PART II!!! post it
Posted by: buy viagra at Jan 21, 2010 9:15:09 AM
i just love it.
Posted by: cell phones for sale at Feb 13, 2010 6:17:30 PM
i didnt this it that way . Great post. Thanks.
Posted by: wow strategy guide at Feb 13, 2010 6:18:28 PM
I think the professor has a good point in this question - art must not be regulated, its main purpose is to serve people and gladden them on day to day basis.
Posted by: Viagra at Feb 23, 2010 3:59:55 AM
Honesty, integrity and a persuasive mentality are the most important qualities of an elected official
otzyvy ob analnom sekse
Posted by: popki v trusikah at Jun 11, 2010 1:59:07 AM
thanks for the article
Posted by: Evelyn at Jun 21, 2010 3:48:03 AM